Skip to Content

13 Best 5 star hotels in Sandusky, OH (2022)

5 star hotels in Sandusky, OH

1. Sawmill Creek Resort (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 400 Sawmill Creek Dr W, Huron, OH 44839
  • Phone: (419) 433-3800
  • Ratings: 4.0 (1148 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Sawmill Creek Resort
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Relaxed accommodations in a waterfront resort with a golf course, a marina, pools & restaurants.

About this hotel

Sitting on a 235-acre site on Sawmill Creek/Lake Erie, this relaxed resort is adjacent to Sheldon Marsh Nature Preserve and 7.2 miles from the amusement parks at Cedar Point.The casual rooms and suites feature coffeemakers, free Wi-Fi and cable TV; some have fireplaces, minifridges, wet bars, rustic decor and/or whirlpool tubs.The property features an 18-hole golf course, a marina and shops set in an 1887 barn. Dining options include a warm restaurant overlooking the creek, an Irish pub, a seafood restaurant and a casual deli. There’s also a private beach, and indoor and outdoor pools. Water sports are available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Some guests complained about the kitchenettes
  • 1 min drive to Sheldon Marsh State Nature Preserve
  • Guests mentioned “brunch” 29 times
  • Guests liked “golf courses”, mentioned 24 times in reviews
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Loril Wash

We were excited to stay here after the renovations Rooms and lobby are very nice, but they just weren’t quite ready for guests which very much detracted from the stay Pros: beds and pillows were quite comfortable

All the staff we encountered were quite nice Drinks were cold and well made Cons: we were unable to get any lunch or dinner at the resort The Mulligan pub is opened, but the cooks called in while we were there Elevator in our building was down so I had to lug all our luggage up the stairs Ice machine also not yet operating Pools are nice, but we were kicked out after about 15 minutes because the pH was off and they had to adjustIn short, I’d likely give it a second chance but not this close to reopen Not worth the price without the amenities

Sandra Schrom

Resort is a nice change of pace from our normal Cedar Point hotel stays The location was great (far enough away from CP for relaxation, but yet close enough to still go) The resort was very nice with an upscale feel

Common areas were updated and very nice! Enjoyed the classy/laid back music played by the live band in the evening Also plenty to do outside with nature trail walks, beach, corn hole and other outdoor games as well Main negative was the outdoor pool was down for our entire stay In all, had a great stay and will definitely go back!

Anna Jolliff

My wife and I stayed here for three nights for our cedar point honeymoon We loved it They had everything we needed at check in for our cedar point visits (parking, early entry, etc)

Unlike what was mentioned in previous reviews, the hotel did not seem understaffed at all, and the pool was open (and great!) The fitness center has all the basics for a strength or cardio workout The breakfast buffet is impressive The one downside is that the rooms do not have coffee makers, but we saw this ahead of time in reviews so we brought our own coffee (Starbucks Via instant coffee packets Does not taste like instant coffee!) We are a gay couple and felt completely welcome here

2. South Beach Resort Hotel Cottages and Marina (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Overlooking Sandusky Bay, this casual resort is 5.3 miles from the African Safari Wildlife Park and 5.5 miles from East Harbor State Park.Relaxed quarters come with free Wi-Fi and TVs. Most have in-room whirlpool tubs, while some have balconies, bay windows and/or pull-out sofas. Suites add minifridges, microwaves and coffeemakers, while cottages add kitchenettes.Amenities include a private beach, 3 outdoor pools (1 kiddie pool), a sundeck and a volleyball court. There’s also a marina with a fishing pier, plus a spa offering Swedish massages and aromatherapy facials.

Things You Need to Know

  • 6 min drive to The Watering Hole Safari and Waterpark (Monsoon Lagoon)
  • Guests praised the service
  • Some guests complained about the beds and others disliked the kitchenettes
  • Guests mentioned “a tennis court” 15 times
  • Guests liked the views
  • The hotel has a game room
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an outdoor pool
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a beach

Feedback From Real Customers

Evan Bart

Our stay at South Beach Resort was amazing! The hotel was extremely well kept and the resort property is beautiful! The views of Lake Erie are top notch There is something to do for everyone including the pool, shuffleboard, and volleyball We really enjoyed how the resort is in close proximity to everything, including Cedar Point

We will definitely stay again if we get the opportunity and you should to!

nelson love

Me and my best friend and kids in tow went during the week of 6/14/22-6/17/22 Experience was awesome! Room was clean as advertised, staff very polite, everyone who was there on vacation was very polite, we all spoke to each other I can’t praise them enough

Fresh towels each day Continental breakfast was more than just donuts and coffee! It was ALSO pancakes, dry cereal, juice/tea, oatmeal if you wanted to make it, just awesome! Grounds were well kept, facilities were clean, if there were any issues they were resolved immediately WE WILL BE BACK! We were very VERY impressed The local people were also very friendly

Shawn H

I have a large group looking for lodging for an event two years away I thought this place might work well for our group When I looked, the queen hotel rooms were listed at $129-$169 per night (there is confusing pricing on their website, it says that room starts at $129 on one page and the next it says it starts at $149)

The website also says that you need to call to book the cottages I called this “resort” and spoke to Fred, who I believe is the owner’s father I asked if they would be willing to open the cottages earlier than typical for this event, if we could book them all Fred explained that due to April’s questionable weather in NE Ohio, they could not open the cottages earlier than May However, he noted that the hotel would be open and would work for our group I talked to the group and we agreed that this hotel would work The very next day we went to book the rooms and the same room was $401/night!! This feels so dirty and slimy These rooms are still listed at the $149 price the weekends before and after!! This exorbitant price increase was never mentioned when I talked to Fred the day before! This is NE OHIO, in April, at a 3-star hotel with iffy reviews! Needless to say, we are not staying here where the owners are shysters I should have heeded the warnings of the many other 1-star reviews BEWARE

3. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Sandusky, an IHG Hotel (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Overlooking Sandusky Bay, this unpretentious hotel is 3 miles from Cedar Point amusement park and less than a mile from the Pipe Creek Wilderness Area.Casual rooms include free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and coffeemakers. Upgraded rooms add whirlpool tubs. Suites feature wet bars, microwaves and minifridges, as well as living areas; some have pull-out sofas.Parking is complimentary, as is continental breakfast served in a relaxed dining area. Other amenities include an indoor pool and a fitness room, plus a business center.

Things You Need to Know

  • 4 min drive to Cedar Point
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned the rooms are unclean
  • Some guests complained about the kitchenettes
  • Some guests disliked the bathrooms
  • Guests mentioned “ice cream” 15 times
  • The fitness center has elliptical machines and treadmills
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Sarah Craig

We stayed at this hotel because of the star rating I wish I would have read the reviews instead Our room wasn’t very clean and the toilet seat was loose

There was no bar of soap, only pump containers that were less than half full for a family of 4 One of the queen beds was broken and wobbly Only 1 small trash can in the bathroom, none in the room itself We couldn’t find any ice machines on any floor Pool was tiny and looked cloudy The only plus is that it is close to Cedar Point The breakfast was good except there was no orange juice

Katherine Ott

Originally booked our stay at another hotel that ended up being filthy! After lots of stress and some tears, I found this hotel had an available room last minute, and I’m so thankful it did! Ended up being much closer to cedar point than our original booking, and the hotel itself was much, much nicer After explaining our headache to the manager, I believe named Todd, he kindly gave us a room with a bay view! Amazing customer service from him, and from his staff that we interacted with Anything we needed was quickly provided upon request, no issues with our room whatsoever

Large breakfast with plenty of options Next door is an awesome and unique restaurant and game lounge as well

George Terplan

My stay here was good overall I am not sure why, but I never had any room service all week other than the one day I requested to have it done The breakfast service was standard for any HI Exp, but they don’t have any orange juice here

My room was great overall and I slept comfortably in the bed and lastly the front desk staff was very friendly and time I needed something

4. Hampton Inn Sandusky-Central (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 6100 Milan Rd, Sandusky, OH 44870
  • Phone: (419) 609-9000
  • Ratings: 4.3 (458 reviews) Very good Eco-certified
  • Website : Hampton Inn Sandusky-Central
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Casual hotel with free hot breakfast & Wi-Fi, plus an exercise room & an indoor pool.

About this hotel

This modern hotel is 6.9 miles from Cedar Point Amusement Park and 3.6 miles from the Sheldon Marsh Nature Preserve.Relaxed rooms include free Wi-Fi and custom-designed beds, plus both full and lap desks (for working on the bed), flat-screen TVs and coffeemakers. Some rooms provide pull-out sofas.Free perks include parking, hot breakfast and weekday breakfast bags to go. There’s also an exercise room, a business center, an indoor pool and a whirlpool.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms, which have TVs
  • The rooms have coffee makers and microwaves
  • 5 min drive to Kalahari Resorts & Conventions
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests liked the hot tub, mentioned 14 times in reviews
  • Guests praised the indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Brett Baron

Absolutely phenomenal service, from the gentleman at the front desk, the ladies that clean the rooms and the ladies that provided breakfast, all these wonderful people cared to make our experience the absolute best it could be The rooms were very clean, the food at breakfast was delicious I highly recommend and will definitely stay again without question

Meg Jo

The hotel is outdated There is a barely working elevator The complimentary breakfast was actually better than most! And the beds were comfortable

The lighting in the hotel was very dim and grim feeling though There is an indoor pool Just not worth the amount they charge a night with so many nice updated hotels charging the same all around

emily baron

Art, the property manager was extremely welcoming when we arrived We booked our room that morning after checking out of another hotel There weren’t any rooms available yet and he offered to text us when a room was ready

The housekeeping staff went above and beyond to help us during our stay and the mor ing breakfast crew was so pleasant and on top of their job, especially with all of the hungry baseball players We will now only stay at Hampton inn when we travel

5. Best Western Plus Sandusky Hotel & Suites (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set along Route 250, this relaxed all-suite hotel is 3 miles both from the Ghostly Manor Thrill Center and from the Osborn Recreation Area.The casual suites offer free Wi-Fi, flat-screens and desks, plus microwaves, minifridges and coffeemakers. All include living areas with sofabeds. Upgraded suites add whirlpool tubs.A breakfast buffet and parking are complimentary. Other amenities include a 24/7 fitness center and an indoor pool. There’s also a business center, meeting space and a coin-operated laundry.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests mentioned the rooms are large
  • The rooms have refrigerators and microwaves
  • 5 min drive to Kalahari Resorts & Conventions
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned hot tubs 30 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

momma.m.87

Location is great, right by so many things The service was AMAZING My teen gets bouts of anxiety inspired insomnia and couldn’t stay in the room over night

The staff were so accommodating to him and his needs Kept an extra eye on him and made him feel comfortable The pool/work out room leave a little to be desired but my kids liked it Breakfast was only okay but honestly it was food and it was hot Everything was very clean As someone who used to be a house keeper in a hotel I know the things I’m looking to be clean and it was great Only things I really have to “complain” about isn’t really a them thing but a ME thing The beds were a bit small for me I’m used to a bigger bed but that by no means is there fault Over all when we return to the area we will most likely be staying again Thank you

Patricia Gulzar

When we walked in room 309, we were concerned that the beds would be uncomfortable because they were both sloped downward toward the headboard Fortunately, the beds didn’t cause an issue too much Our room wasn’t clean

This included the toilet, floor, and bed Because the hotel was full, we couldn’t switch rooms, which is understandable I did request for our room to be clean, but that never happened The lights in the bathroom kept cutting on and off I was happy to leave

Jeffrey Dean

I always have the best stays at Best Western hotels, and this didn’t disappoint Off season rates were excellent Yeah, it’s still a little pricey if you’re just looking for shelter

But so clean and comfortable, with an enormous comfortable bed, super clean bathroom with amenities such as a safe, coffee maker, fridge and breakfast I dinged it for the tiny pillows and scratchy towels, which seemed more in place at a Travelodge, but otherwise, it really was a 5 star stay

6. Red Fern Inn at Rocky Point Winery

About this hotel

111 W Main St, Marblehead, OH 43440(419) 967-5344

Things You Need to Know

  • 2 min drive to the Marblehead Light
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests liked the rooms, mentioned 18 times in reviews
  • Guests praised the nightlife
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

gary turner

Visited on June 21, pretty sweet Very nice Reno and the winery added a great optionWe left our car at the Inn, walked to KI ferry

Avoided $15 Parking fee The Inn is highly recommended Everyone was top shelf

Anthony Salem

Stayed one night in celebration of our 20th wedding anniversary The room was comfortable and clean The staff was friendly and very helpful

There was a complimentary bottle of wine and cheese tray waiting for us Even though the winery closed at six (Monday in October) we were allowed to sit out back at one of the fire pits to enjoy our wine and cheese We would definitely come back for the inn and the winery both

7. Our Sunset Place Bed & Breakfast

About this hotel

Set on the shores of Lake Erie and backed by trees, this laid-back B&B is 3 miles from both the Liberty Aviation Museum and Erie-Ottawa International Airport, and 5 miles from scenic views at East Harbor State Park.The 4 warmly decorated rooms come with free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and en suite bathrooms, as well as views of the lake. Some add furnished balconies and/or whirlpool tubs.Breakfast is served in an informal dining room, or on a furnished deck that has lake views. There’s also a low-key bar. Parking is available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the bathrooms
  • 5 min drive to the African Safari Wildlife Park
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub

Feedback From Real Customers

Susan Clary

The inn is beautiful excellent stay even though the weather was very nasty It was cold and raining Our room was luxurious with a king sized bed, awesome shower with jets that massages an aching back

We had an amazing view of the lake right outside our room which also had a little deck with a table and chairs Innkeepers we’re accommodating letting us check in a little early Breakfast was delicious We will definitely be back when the weather will be a bit more predictable

8. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Milan – Sandusky Area, an IHG Hotel (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Facing a highway, this straightforward hotel is 2 miles from I-80/I-90, 4 miles from waterslides at Kalahari Resorts Sandusky and 12 miles from the Cedar Point amusement park.Down-to-earth rooms feature Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, as well as minifridges, microwaves and Keurig coffeemakers. Suites add sitting areas with sofabeds.A breakfast buffet is served in a casual dining room. Other amenities include a heated indoor pool, an exercise room, and a patio with a fire pit. Parking is also available.

Things You Need to Know

  • The down-to-earth rooms have TVs and coffee makers
  • 6 min drive to the Thomas Alva Edison Birthplace
  • Guests praised the service
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Scott

We were in the area for a volleyball tournament and this was the hotel the team stayed in Our room was a nice size and was clean The only issue we had was that there was a stale smoke smell by the fridge

From what our daughter and her teammates said the pool was ok and wasn’t too small If she plays in this tournament next year we will be recommending this hotel as our place to stay

Travis Zuleger

Had a really unfortunate experience last night A very loud party of 5 was drinking on the back patio from 10:30 until 1:30 We called the front desk multiple times, walked down to the desk, and even directly asked the party to quiet down

Management asked them to quiet down when quiet hours kicked in at 11:00 but it wasn’t effective At 11:30 we were told that the cops were called after an aggressive confrontation at the front desk but we continued to hear the yelling and laughing until 1:30 I appreciate the attempt to help from the ladies at the front desk but this situation could have been handled so much better

Drew Price

Overall this place was exactly what I would expect from a Holiday Inn Express Staff was very kind Hotel was well kept up

There was at least a fitness center (wish it went higher than 50lbs)The only complaint I could think of is the elevator is super slow and in the room I stayed in it the bathroom door was open the mini fridge was blocked by the door That nitpicking though

9. Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Sandusky (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

In a residential area off Highway 250, this casual hotel is 6 miles from Castaway Bay water park and 10 miles from Cedar Point amusement park.Informal rooms offer free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and desks with ergonomic chairs, as well as coffeemakers, minifridges and microwaves. Upgraded rooms add whirlpool tubs; suites have living areas and sofabeds.Hot breakfast and parking are free. Other amenities include an indoor pool, a fitness center, a business center and guest laundry facilities.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms and the beds
  • Guests liked the friendly service
  • Some guests complained about the bathrooms
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • The fitness center has elliptical machines and treadmills
  • Guests praised the indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Valerie Gonzalez

We ended up at this hotel because we found bed bugs at our original hotel at 11pm and this was the only one with good reviews that still had rooms left Nathan at the front desk was wonderful He was very kind and empathetic, as well as energetic for it being after midnight

The beds were comfortable and the room was very clean Since it was so late we didn’t get to use most amenities like the pool so I can’t speak on that The breakfast was good, but very crowded Staff had trouble keeping up with refilling the stations due to so many people The price was high, but it was worth it to have a clean, comfortable place to stay with no bed bugs We would stay here again

Debbie Derrenberger

Unfortunately we didnt make it through our first night because of a family emergency, but the check in/check out was easy and Alyssa & Michelle were awesome! Thank you also for recognizing our Anniversary with a card and some snacks, something no other hotel has ever done for us!! Our room was very clean and smelled great Plenty of towels and bed was comfy Looking forward to making a return visit

10. Farrell House Lodge (4-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set in a stately building on the wooded grounds of Sunnybrook Trout Club, this upmarket guesthouse off Route 6 is a mile from Firelands Winery and 9 miles from African Safari Wildlife Park.The 9 individually decorated, country-style rooms have private or en suite bathrooms, plus Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs. Upgraded rooms add sitting areas and/or fireplaces. A rustic cabin and a 4-bedroom farmhouse provide kitchens.The grounds feature a 10-acre pond; canoe and kayak rentals are free. Other amenities include a warm lounge, a game room, and a porch with rocking chairs. A breakfast buffet and lunch are available. Minimum-stay rules may apply.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms
  • 2 min drive to Firelands Winery & Restaurant
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Tom Hamilton

Very accommodating We are very glad we stayed here and would do so againWe had one of the smaller ‘Servants Quarters” so not the largest of rooms, but adequate and valued right for the price paid

Staff was eager to please Breakfast was very well doneThe grounds are amazing and we only were sorry it rained before we could fully explore the river and gardens

Beth M

Absolutely magical! I booked this B&B on a whim for a work trip to Sandusky I stumbled into a hidden gem! This is a pristine, 65 acre property and a step back in time The owner, Doug, greeted me, gave me great dinner recommendations and and shared some great history about the house

Breakfast was outstanding with a beautiful view of the grounds The owners have thought of everything and ensure every amentiy is available The locations is great; only minutes to the waterfront, the ferry lines, Catawba island and many elevated casual dining/winery choices

Jenna Agosta

We were only able to stay one night, but will definitely be going back in the future! This place doesn’t even feel like Ohio It is so beautiful!! The grounds are gorgeous and the lodge itself is so cute Breakfast is included and exceeded our expectations

We had apple French toast, but I am sure everything is great We were nervous about staying here, because we were younger than most guests, but everyone was super friendly This place is the hidden gem of Ohio Thank you!!!

11. Tru by Hilton Sandusky (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 6110 Milan Rd, Sandusky, OH 44870
  • Phone: (419) 625-8000
  • Ratings: 4.3 (200 reviews) Very good Eco-certified
  • Website : Tru by Hilton Sandusky
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Casual hotel offering an indoor pool, a gym & a bright lobby lounge, plus a patio with fire pits.

About this hotel

Off Highway 250, this informal hotel with modern decor is 4 miles from the Sports Force Parks/Cedar Point Sports Center, 7 miles from Cedar Point amusement park and 9 miles from Cedar Point Beach.Bright, streamlined rooms have flat-screen TVs, Wi-Fi and minifridges.Amenities include an indoor pool and a gym, as well as a terrace with fire pits. A colorful lobby lounge features work space, a business center and a 24-hour convenience store. A hot breakfast buffet and parking are available.

Things You Need to Know

  • The rooms have TVs and microwaves
  • 4 min drive to Kalahari Resorts & Conventions
  • Guests praised the clean rooms but some thought they were small
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests mentioned beds 12 times

Feedback From Real Customers

Terri Maiorana

Our stay was great – room was clean and staff was very pleasant and helpful Only downfall was that the hotel was completely full and parking was full The only spot was a handicap spot in the back of the building so we parked there at 10:30pm

At 3:30am we received a ticket for $25000 – we had no other parking option but here We let the front desk know what happened and they were very apologetic The manager called me the next day and was very helpful and completely made things right with us Amazing customer service! We will definitely stay here again – especially for the way the whole situation was handled Great job on the way you take care of your guests

Ashley Galvin

Arrived here with my daughter for a weekend basketball tournament After a minor issue with our first room, the person at the front desk (unfortunately I didn’t get her name!) Switched our room with no issue! Ultra sleek, modern, funky hotel and the beds were so comfortable! We didn’t utilize the pool, but it was a nice pool area! Definitely will stay here again!

Daigo Kobayashi

Neat and new hotel with a good access to Cedar Point at reasonable price!I stayed in a 2 queen-size bed room when I visited the Cedar Point Although the room was not that big, the room was clean and neat You can have a free breakfast between 6 to 10 am

You also have a free parking lot in front of the hotel Overall, I had great experience there

12. Hotel Kilbourne (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 223 W Water St, Sandusky, OH 44870
  • Phone: (844) 373-2223
  • Ratings: 4.4 (194 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Hotel Kilbourne
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Trendy hotel featuring bay views & industrial-style quarters, plus a rooftop bar & a pub.

About this hotel

Across the street from Sandusky Bay, this trendy hotel set among funky shops and eateries is a mile from the nearest train station and 4 miles from Cedar Point amusement park.Featuring partially exposed brick walls, the relaxed, industrial-style rooms come with designer toiletries, free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, as well as minifridges and Nespresso machines. Some offer bay views. Suites add pull-out sofas; an upgraded suite has a separate living room, a wet bar and a private balcony.Amenities include a pub-style lobby bar with floor-to-ceiling windows, plus a rooftop bar overlooking the bay.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms
  • Walking distance to メリーゴーランドミュージアム and Maritime Museum of Sandusky
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Czarina Lyons

We had a very unpleasant experience with this hotel so we do not recommend this hotel to anyone! First, hotel front desk appeared to be nice but unhelpful Upon checking in, I had asked if someone could help me with taking my 2 big suitcases to my room I had my little boy with me so we just needed a little help

The front desk staff responded “sure” So I went to my car, which is parked right in front of the hotel, thinking she would follow me But nope, as I pulled my 2 suitcases and my son holding me, she pretended she didn’t see me Completely ignored me Thankfully, another lady saw me and offered to give me a cart I took the cart, loaded it myself and pushed it to the elevator and to my room As we entered the room, we saw an object on the floor, I picked it up and put it on the table Looked like a remote control for the AC that used to be mounted on the wall had fallen off There were 4 mall screws that supposed to hold it, but you as most of us know, unless there was a stud behind that wall, that thing will never stay I did not think of it as anything I picked it up and whatever A day later after we checked out (we only stayed for 1 night), this hotel charged my card $250 for damage in the room I called the hotel right away but front desk said the hotel manager was not in so she took my message I sent an email and no response I have contacted multiple times and emailed multiple times and I have not gotten any response from the manager of this hotel Hopefully, this review will work and would get their attention (I hope so as it has been 1 week) This is unacceptable!It is also very loud, we hear footsteps from the room above us The bed is not comfortable at all And room is not spacious

Danielle Franck

This hotel nearly ruined our wedding Aside from the onsite restaurant giving my husband and several others in our group food poisoning from the rehearsal dinner, the front desk manager made our wedding day a nightmare We booked this hotel specifically because we wanted to get ready here and have pictures taken on the rooftop bar

When we checked in, we told the girl at the front desk we would have people arriving between 8-8:30 and to please let them know where our room was To our surprise the following morning, the front desk isn’t even staffed from 12am until 11am when the bar opens back up! So when you wake up and need more towels after your husband has been throwing up all night, there is no way to get any When your hair and make up artist arrive, be prepared to run downstairs each time to let them in the front door If you won’t be ready to check out by 11am, (even if you have multiple issues caused by the hotel), be prepared to be charged or kicked out of your room! And then when we went to take our pictures in the rooftop bar, we were told we were not allowed because of a liability even though we were told ahead of time we could Then to save face, they told us the door was frozen shut The best part of all of this – when I spoke with the owner to see how she wanted to proceed in making the situation right, she offered us a night at the hotel or a gift card to the restaurant or gift shop, both of which are no use to us I had really hoped that a business owner would want to make this right, but she showed no interested in that at all Very disappointed

Coleman Dole

Service, rooms, and location were all excellent I was blown away by the restaurant below and the quality of the hotel In my opinion this is the nicest place to stay in Sandusky

We looked at nearby AirBNBs and there’s one in the condos across the street, and that had an egregious $150 cleaning base-charge And I feel like they’d have similar sound issues based on proximity (see below)Only caveat is that the walls / windows are ‘thin’ and you can hear quite a bit However, that’s something that I’ve mostly come to expect During my stay I heard the trash truck outside at 7am Not bad at all No gripes about the sound but other people noted this in their reviews and while I can see how it is an issue for some, I’ve experienced worse at other hotelsOtherwise I really, thoroughly enjoyed staying at Hotel Kilbourne The staff was awesome, the rooms were awesome, and the location is awesome (walked to Mr Smith’s coffee shop every morning, walked to restaurants nearby for dinner) Note that the hotel is smaller than the average chain hotel, so you may want to book ahead of time I Highly recommend Hotel Kilbourne!

Featured Options

HotelTonight.com

13. Kelleys Island Venture Resort

About this hotel

Accessible by boat or plane only, this polished all-suite hotel on an island in southern Lake Erie is 1.9 miles from Kelleys Island State Park.The refined suites offer Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, plus minifridges, microwaves and coffeemakers. All suites have separate living areas, and some add private patios or balconies with lake views.Breakfast is available. Other amenities include an outdoor pool, a hot tub, a 3-tiered deck with barbecues, and a children’s playground.

Things You Need to Know

  • The rooms have kitchenettes
  • 6 min drive to Kelleys Island State Park
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an outdoor pool
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub

Feedback From Real Customers

Sunshine

I had left a message a couple of days ago and someone by the name of Sarah I believe (honestly I don’t really care what her name was) was really rude to me and I was taken back by it I said, ” oh hi thank you so much for calling me back She says, What did you need”

Really that’s how you talk to someone who may be a potential paying customer? I told her that my sister was getting married in July and was wanting to stay on Kelly’s Island for her bachelorette party Before I could say anything else she says, “I’m going to stop you right there” (wow) We don’t allow bachelorette parties to stay here This is a family oriented place it’s listed on our website” I said oh okay well I didn’t look on your website, that’s why I’m calling you because I had a few questions first before I booked rooms and we’re not l that type of bachelorette party and there are not really any other options to stay at on Kelly’s Island for one night We just wanted something for one night” I mean really there was no reason for her to be rude and demeaning towards me all because I asked a question regarding a bachelorette party It was truly unnecessary and she could have spoken to me in a better manner and handled it more professionally This was a turn off and I don’t believe I want to ever stay there at all

Barb Ann Hite

My husband and I stayed at the resort a few weeks ago Very clean, quiet and a fantastic pool! We called after we were almost back home to ask if they had found a pair of plastic shoe inserts While no one at that point had found them and turned them in , their staff searched the pool area where I thought they may be

They took the time to look, found them and called us the next day They were mailed back to me very soon Will never forget the kindness they showed in going out of their way to find these items!

Sharing is caring!