Skip to Content

18 Best 5 star hotels in Shirley, NY (2022)

5 star hotels in Shirley, NY

1. Hyatt Place Long Island/East End (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set on Long Island’s North Fork, this informal hotel overlooking the Peconic River is a mile from the Long Island Aquarium.Casual, warmly furnished rooms provide free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and separate living areas with sofabeds, as well as minifridges and coffeemakers. Upgraded rooms have views of the river and harbor.Parking is complimentary. There are indoor and outdoor pools, plus a 24-hour gym and a business center. Dining options include a cafe/bar and a snack shop.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the large rooms
  • Walking distance to the Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center and the Railroad Museum of Long Island
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned pools 46 times
  • Guests praised the views
  • The fitness center has weight machines

Feedback From Real Customers

Madeleine Metzler

We booked a block of rooms with this hotel for our wedding weekend on the North Fork of Long Island We worked with Suzanne Lincoln who was SO incredibly helpful in arranging the block, sharing information, answering questions, and assisting with last-minute requests All our guests were very happy with their stays and it was nice to be able to gather with other guests in the spacious lobby, at the bar, and over breakfast

We would absolutely recommend this property for groups or for family travelers One thing that could be improved is the layout of the rooms There was no closet (which for a wedding with lots of things to hang was challenging) and the room arrangement was a little strange Also, we were staying off-season and it was very hard to find food, coffee, lunch within walking distance of the hotel The hotel restaurants are either not open off-season or are closed from Monday-Wednesday which is when we were there There are very limited take-out/delivery options in Riverhead You would need to drive to get food, which might not be ideal for everyone But, honestly, all the staff at the Hyatt were amazing and so great to work with They were patient and helpful and we would definitely return and recommend it to others

2. Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

In a commercial area with offices and eateries, this relaxed hotel is 8 miles from walking trails at Connetquot River State Park Preserve, and 7 miles from Corey Beach on the Patchogue Bay. Long Island MacArthur Airport is 3 miles away.Straightforward studios feature free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and sofabeds, as well as kitchenettes and dining areas. The 1-bedroom apartments add separate living rooms and extra TVs.Complimentary perks include breakfast, an airport shuttle, and evening socials with snacks and drinks. Other amenities consist of an indoor pool and a fitness center. Parking is available for a fee.

Things You Need to Know

  • 11 min drive to Lakeland County Park
  • 10 min walk to nearest train station
  • Guests mentioned pools 11 times

Feedback From Real Customers

APet

Every hallway in the hotel WREAKED of marijuana GM said that since marijuana is legal that there isn’t anything that can be done about it—Hey GM, smoking cigarettes is legal too

Don’t sell a room that says NON-SMOKING then People have allergies to smoke—like me The mattresses had stains GM said that’s normal except the BIG ONE that we saw—she thought that was too much But all of the other stains were acceptable according to her The slick move of charging $10 a day for “parking with security” without mentioning it prior to booking meanwhile I did not see “security” NOT ONCE I was in and out of the hotel all day and night for an entire week GM says they mention the parking fee on their website I told her we booked through bookingcom—she said she isn’t responsible for what they say or don’t say What a scam The ladies at the front desk were very pleasant That was the only thing that was good at this MOTEL What a disappointment Homewood Suites has no integrity

L Ramos

We always try to book in a Homewood suites since there are 7 of us We had hoped to enjoy our stay by spending time in the pool

Unfortunately it was closed for maintenance the entire time we were there This was a major inconvenience as we had purposely booked our trip in the middle of winter in a place that had an indoor pool The room was fine, no issues, but not having access to the pool ruined the trip with no recourse

Amanda Grey

***DON’T STAY HERE!!!***Maids must have smoked in the room both before and after we arrived for a quick stay on our way to a family funeral Since neither of us smoke, and I have asthma, I wanted to report the room immediately because the smoke was disgusting but we had no time We went to the wake, came back to sleep, left early for the funeral and the manager is swearing that we smoked in the room and charging us

Liar liar pants on fire Don’t stay here The maids will screw you and you will literally pay with your wallet since the manager does not believe honest guests

3. Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Off Interstate 495, this modern all-suite hotel is 4 miles from Lake Ronkonkoma and 9 miles from Stony Brook University.Warm studios offer free Wi-Fi, kitchenettes and pull-out sofas, along with flat-screen TVs. Suites add separate living areas.Freebies include hot breakfast, parking, a grocery delivery service, and weekday evening socials with snacks. There’s also a gym, an indoor pool and a sports court, plus BBQs and laundry facilities. Other amenities include a 24/7 business center and a convenience store.

Things You Need to Know

  • 13 min drive to Connetquot River State Park Preserve
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests praised the kitchenettes but some complained about the beds
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “dogs” 14 times
  • Guests mentioned “movie theaters” 14 times
  • Guests praised the nightlife
  • Guests praised the indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Sarah Sumrall

I chose this hotel because they advertise an airport shuttle, which they do not have in service Therefore, I had to spend nearly $50 for an Uber Additionally, I had an early flight

The checking person told me there would be a few breakfast items to grab on my way out However, there was nothing, not even coffee available with no one in sight at the front desk The room at least was very nice and clean

David Wright

This place has really gone downhill Sofas and chairs are ancient and sag to a point of being unusable The counters are wiped clean but it it is clear from the grease on cupboards that others have been cooking there

Air conditioner is so noisy you can’t sleep No hot water one night The staff is friendly and helpful but clearly the place is not taken care of

Marilyn Clarke

On 3/26/2022 I stayed at the Marriott Residence Inn in Holtsville, NY Before arrival my sister called and spoke with Gio Guilfucci to request a credit authorization form so she could put her credit card down as payment for my stay Gio was so friendly and provided very prompt service, when I arrived I was greeted with a smile and the whole check in process was such a pleasure

I felt very welcomed and attended to, I would definitely recommend this hotel just on the customer service alone I look forward to booking again 😊 Thank you again Gio and Marriott for the wonderful stay!!!

4. Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

This no-frills budget hotel is just off Interstate 495, 8.8 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport and 18 miles from Splish Splash Water Park.All rooms and suites include free WiFi and have private bathrooms with showers, as well as flat-screen TVs and coffeemakers. Some rooms include minifridges and microwaves.A complimentary hot breakfast buffet is provided and there’s free parking for vehicles of all sizes. Other amenities include a fitness center, business center and guest laundry facilities.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the clean rooms and praised the beds
  • 11 min drive to Southaven County Park
  • 8 min walk to nearest train station
  • Guests liked the friendly service
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Jen Knox

Was rather satisfied with my stay at this establishment Check in was smooth, pretty decent parking lot, decent food choices within walking distance Room was clean, water pressure was instant and hot (no lag time)

Ample room for my computer and other items I brought with me (suitcase) Beds were a little hard, but nothing terrible It appeared they had a wide fresh variety of breakfast, however, I opted for the Starbucks next door Overall, if I am ever out this way I would stay here again

Cassidy Clark

A really nice hotel the staff is just awesome unlike any hotel I’ve ever stayed at n I travel for a living this place has a full nice breakfast every morning an ATM in the lobby a laundry room & spacious rooms wit space between the bathroom and the bedroom for more privacy the rates r lower than the run down hotels where some of my coworkers r staying I would definitely recommend this hotel to my family and friends

S Hsieh

The room I stayed in (Room #200) for 1 night had soaked carpet from either a rain storm or leaking air conditioner The room also smelled which was probably mold I checked in late at 9pm and had unpacked so it was too late to ask for another room (stayed 1 night only)

Anyway, Comfort Inn should not be giving flooded, moldy rooms to customers and charging them $150 per night Also, the fitness center had damaged equipment in which customers could potentially injure themselves

5. SpringHill Suites by Marriott Long Island Brookhaven (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

A 4-mile drive from Southaven County Park, this contemporary all-suite hotel is 5 miles from the Gateway Playhouse and 6 miles from the Patchogue Theatre.The chic, modern studios have kitchenettes, separate living areas and pull-out sofas, as well as desks, flat-screen TVs and free Wi-Fi.Complimentary perks include parking and hot breakfast. There’s also an indoor pool and a fitness room; coin-operated laundry facilities are available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the large rooms
  • 5 min drive to Southaven County Park
  • Some guests complained about the bathrooms
  • Guests mentioned the service is friendly
  • Guests mentioned “waffles” 10 times
  • Guests praised the fitness center
  • Guests liked the indoor pool
  • Guests praised the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Sonia

Nice, spacious, comfortable rooms with nice amenities Loved the separate work / sitting area that is separated from the bedroom Also liked that the toilet was separate from the bathroom

Beds and pillows were comfy and soft…made for a good night’s rest Front desk staff was super friendly and welcoming Breakfast was great and breakfast staff were very kind and friendly too Overall a great stay…highly recommended!!!

Sarah Young

I had an amazing time here at Springhill! The staff is amazing especially Tom from the front desk! But everyone was super nice and Friendly The rooms are cleaned everyday (Unless you don’t want) plenty of parking

Breakfast is basic but hot and delicious I would recommend everyone to stay here The only disappointment was that the pool was closed due to construction

Valentino Tartamella

The rooms are nice and clean, as one would expect, and the hotel features a tiny pool and fitness area for hotel members The complimentary breakfast is more casual; there is little hot food, one waffle maker, some pastries, coffee, and juice You have everything you need to have a nice stay, and the staff here are very friendly, but the reason for my low review is you’re paying premium prices for an average experience

Wait for some discounts to come and then reserve a night here

6. Holiday Inn Long Island – Islip Arpt East, an IHG Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Opposite medical offices on a tree-lined road, this relaxed hotel is 6 miles from Corey Beach on Patchogue Bay and 8 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport. Long Island Aquarium is 21 miles away.Understated rooms feature Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and sitting areas, as well as minifridges, microwaves, and tea and coffeemaking facilities. Suites add wet bars and living rooms. Room service is offered.An airport shuttle is complimentary. There’s also a casual restaurant/bar and a 24-hour fitness center. Parking and breakfast are available, as is meeting and event space.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms and the beds
  • 11 min drive to Southaven County Park
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests praised the friendly, professional service
  • Guests praised the lobby
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Dajania Tireth

I stayed for one night for a wedding occuring at the hotel The staff was welcoming and kind, however, aside from nice front desk employees, there were too many cons to make it worth the absurd priceI booked a room and they did not give me the block price because I called 20 days from the wedding

I was told the group discount expires a month prior to the wedding and I should have booked sooner Okay, fine The 1 night stay was $328 including taxes Okay, fineWe had no washcloths in the room They did not have air conditioning on in the hallways It was very stuffy and downright hot The walls were paper thin and I could hear every guest nearby coming and going My $300 room had a view of an enclosed corridor There were no chairs in the room with two queen beds The toilet paper was the cheapest stuff on earth The toiletries were no more than dove body wash bars Breakfast downstairs was sufficient with good portions and good service but was overpricedI feel like this hotel absolutely jacked the prices for guests of the wedding, failed to honor their discount rate, and lacked basic necessities in the rooms

James Williams

Being an IHG customer for over 15 years I’m used to all what IHG has to offerSo with regards to this holiday inn I would give 4 stars mainly surrounding the pricing which is really high considering I’ve stayed in both the Intercontinental Hotels for cheaper in (could of been out of season though) Manhattan Even so the reception were very helpful, kind (even though the first day I was very jet lagged and I wasn’t firing on all cylinders) and professional

Rooms were comfortable with a nice bathroom and good working ACI’d recommend for a short stop over

Kathleen Corbisiero

This was the second time we have stayed here overnight and we will continue to choose this HI for future visits to Long Island The location is conveniently located between the north and south shores, easy to get to, and the restaurant is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner The staff are all kind and courteous and the atmosphere in the lobby is very comfortable

The rooms are very comfortable and have great hot showers! A+

7. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Long Island-East End, an IHG Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This laid-back hotel is 2 miles from the Railroad Museum of Long Island, and 3 miles from both Splish Splash Water Park and Long Island Aquarium.Featuring carpeted floors and wood furnishings, the down-to-earth rooms offer free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and en suite bathrooms. Suites add microwaves, minifridges and sitting areas with pull-out sofas.Complimentary perks include breakfast and parking. Other amenities consist of a 24-hour gym, a heated outdoor pool and meeting space.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the clean rooms and praised the beds
  • 4 min drive to Splish Splash
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests liked the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “bagels” 11 times

Feedback From Real Customers

Brian Fontanella

The room was good, the staff was friendly the breakfast was above average and had many choices My only complaint was the aggressive manner in which they try to force you out of your room in the morning We attended a wedding nearby and obviously wanted to sleep in a little

The cleaning staff used a card key to enter my room at 8am after a quick knock and we were in bed Thankfully I had locked the safety latch and then we went to have breakfast around 9am and the staff was waiting outside of our room and asked are we leaving?? We replied no we are going to get breakfast and then put the do not disturb sign on the door out of fear of being evicted from the room This was just unnecessary in my opinion Check in for the next guests is not till 3pm This should not be my inconvenience to even think about the logistics of how they will clean all of the rooms in time, meanwhile 11-3 all rooms are vacant I would not stay here again unless I had to I believe that this hotel could do a little better even though they probably get by with the steady stream of business from local vineyards and wedding venues

Victoria Ybabez

It is gone downhill since last year we stayed there One of there elevators wasn’t working upon checking in, we realize that we didn’t have any blackout curtains in out room We notified the front desk and they said they would send maintenance in the next morning

I had to call again that next day to make sure that someone was going to come before they left for the day Maintenance had to hang something to black out the room for night time but then we weren’t able to have any natural light for 6 daysThe curtains weren’t working at all in our room Went down to the front desk one morning and to get some extra towels they said they would have housekeeping bring them up to us and they never did had to go back down again, and we had only use housekeeping one time the whole stay Breakfast was good but you have to get down there early Pool was nice! Customer service wise, the girls were great however there was an on duty manager that you could tell hates his job (Manager On DutyNathaly Joya) Husband had a not so good interaction with him Wouldn’t pay that much to stay there again going to stay at one of the other hotels in town the next time we come

Nugget Queen

First night was great! Quiet hotel and great breakfast Saturday morning! Saturday night wasn’t so pleasant, Girls Dance Team or whatever checked in and it was incredibly noisy and loud then They were running up and down the hallway screaming and just acting like it was a playground Didn’t get any sleep and Was hoping to enjoy breakfast but again the girls dance team ruined that as well

8. Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Flanked by greenery, this unfussy all-suite hotel off the Long Island Expressway is 5 miles from both the Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge and Brookhaven National Laboratory.Colorful, warmly furnished studios feature kitchenettes, Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, as well as sitting areas with sofabeds. Suites have separate living rooms.There’s a gym and an indoor pool, plus 1,908 sq ft of meeting and event space. Hot breakfast and parking are available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the kitchenettes and the beds
  • 8 min drive to Brookhaven State Park
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Nicole Berthiaume

Was only there for one night but was very impressed Friendly, clean, and helpful front desk Highly recommended places to eat and definitely not steered in the wrong direction–delicious

Check in was simple and quick Pet friendly rooms were perfect clean and you couldn’t even tell it was a pet friendly place to stay Booked another stay in a few weeks

Niefa Myhand

The staff at this hotel was very nice , very helpful One of the staff ladies actually helped me prepare for my sons birthday party , the hotel & the suites were very very clean The breakfast in the morning definitely came in handy , these kids woke up so hungry

The pool area was very nice with the patio Loved every bit of our trip , I would definitely come back & refer to a friend/ family GREAT JOB STAFFF!

Jeff A.

This is our second time staying here, Very clean and comfortable staff are friendly, I’m staying here for more than a week so I wanted the top floor they have 4 floors they gave me the 3rd The people above us you can hear every footstep Very annoying epecially they get up so early and I have to listen to them walking back and forth

This is not a cheap hotel why can’t they build better floors so I do not have to hear someone above walking back and forth Rooms are very clean comfortable beds mini kitchen which is great Bathroom clean but a bit tightAlso the breakfast was Mediocre Whose idea was it to put whole-grain waffle batter? Really?? Maybe let’s have a choice? Breakfast could be better weak coffee It’s a fairly new hotel but I noticed some wear and tear already from my stay a year ago Bathroom faucet very loose bathroom door lock broken Next year when I come back into town I may think about staying here againRequested the top four I

9. Pines Bluff Overlook

About this hotel

This simple hotel on Fire Island is a minute’s walk from the beach, 1.5 miles from Cherry Grove and 2.8 miles from Sunken Forest.The airy, unassuming rooms and suites all have sliding doors leading out to the deck, private bathrooms, free WiFi, TVs with satellite channels, DVD players, iPod docks and minifridges. There are also wood-panelled apartments available, with sitting areas and kitchens. Daily and weekly rates are available.There’s a free continental breakfast, plus complimentary all-day drinks. Amenities include an outdoor pool, plus loungers and a rooftop hot tub with ocean views. The hotel is open between March and December.

Things You Need to Know

  • The hotel has breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an outdoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Rick Mordecon

Was looking for a comfortable somewhat private retreat in the very busy Fire Island Pines and found it here at Pine Bluffs Our suite was Apartment A Clean, quiet, comfortable bed, air conditioned, Cable TV, great rainhead shower

However, the best part of this spot is the upstairs pool area and the roof deck with a hot tub and excellent views of the Atlantic Continental breakfast was well conceived and the all day snacks and wine at cocktail hour a welcome addition to the amenities for this place Jim and James, our hosts were gracious, nice and helpful in all of our needs and the other guests at the B&B were cool, interesting and private as well A wonderful spot to spend a few days in a beautiful place

Nicholas Veneziale

We were looking for a place just for the weekend as most places rent by the week Despite being out to the Pines for years, never knew about Pines Bluff Have to say, it was a great find and a great stay

Hosts are very nice and accommodating, even upgraded us when our room had an issue prior to our arrival They also gave us an adjacent room since it was vacant so our party of four would be more comfortable Great place to stay, definitely recommend

Richard Garnett

Nice relaxing place and wonderful location! Beautiful views from the hot tub at night, and during the day, and well anything time! Jim is a wonderful host, check out his site for amenities and hospitality (food, snacks, refreshments) Coby, a Boston Terrier with a lovely character and disposition was my therapy while on holiday The place is nice, I’ll come back for Coby! If you’re not an animal person, he won’t bother you

I’ve stayed at a different place each time, this is at the top of the list

10. East Wind Long Island (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 5720 NY-25A, Wading River, NY 11792
  • Phone: (631) 929-3500
  • Ratings: 4.4 (1070 reviews) Very good
  • Website : East Wind Long Island
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Refined hotel with warm, elegant rooms, plus an indoor pool, a spa & a restaurant.

About this hotel

On a tree-lined lawn along Route 25A on Long Island, this upscale hotel with a grand Colonial exterior is 3 miles from Wildwood State Park and 5 miles from Splish Splash Water Park.The warm, sophisticated rooms are TV-less and offer free Wi-Fi, tea and coffeemaking facilities and room service. Upgraded rooms add refined living or dining areas, or whirlpool baths.Parking is complimentary. There’s a stately entranceway with a chandelier and a double staircase. Other amenities include a restaurant, a bar and a spa with a steam room and sauna, plus an indoor pool and a gym offering fitness classes. Excursions, such as wine tours, are also available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests mentioned the rooms are clean
  • Guests praised the beds
  • 10 min walk to Lewin Farms
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests mentioned “Massage” 27 times
  • Guests mentioned “brunch” 24 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • Guests praised the spa

Feedback From Real Customers

liz kavanagh

Absolutely 10 out 5 stars, this place was so great and made my wedding day so special We got married May of 2021 and had originally planned our wedding upstate shortly after getting engaged in 2018 then covid hit in 2020 and 5 months before our wedding our venue canceled We understood that due to covid they had to so we got our deposit back and began our search for a new venue

We came across The East Wind and they were so kind and helpful and we were even able to keep our original wedding date We had a small wedding of about 45 people and they made the day so great and the space was so beautiful Luis our event manager was fantastic and made sure everything went according to plan and that we had everything we needed I would recommend this venue to anyone and everyone Thank you East Wind for making my day so special

Cassandra Ambrosius

The wedding venue was incredible! The food was great, the staff was amazing and the space itself was gorgeous But the hotel is another story The rooms are outdated – pealing wallpaper, cracked sinks, no refrigerator in the room, no fitted sheets

Then the fire alarm went off at 7 am and the hot water had to be turned off The rooms need a makeover

Evelyn Boileau

The staff, our MaitreD Reid was amazing, my bridal assistant was wonderful The food was amazing Our wedding was beautiful

Everything turn out really great As a bride I was well taken care ofWould highly recommend East Wind as a venue for wedding or any event or celebration that you may panningA very special Thank you to Scott who started with us from the very begining Phenomenal service

11. Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook-Long Island, an IHG Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This contemporary hotel is an 11-minute drive from the Long Island Expressway and 15 minutes from Port Jefferson Harbor.Traditional rooms come with desks and flat-screen TVs, plus iPod docking stations, minifridges and microwaves. There’s also free WiFi and high-pressure showerheads in the bathrooms. Kids 19 and under stay free with an adult. Suites add whirlpool tubs.Amenities include a free breakfast bar and an indoor pool, plus a fitness center, sports field and putting green. Free parking and shuttle service are also available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the large, clean rooms and the beds
  • 10 min drive to Gallery North
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests praised the fitness center
  • Guests praised the indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Brian DelloRusso

Upon checking in we inspected the room and found that the bathroom had not been cleaned well (hairs in the tub and a streaky mirror), the little bottles of mouthwash that were left for us were not replaced (one had a broken seal and no protective cap on it) and the floors were not very clean When I called the front desk they were quick to offer a new room and apologized for the inconveniences The second room was cleaner however, the furnishings were no where near as nice

The first room had a nice leather couch, the second room had a couch that looked like it came from a thrift storeThe second and third day we were there the hotel was hosting a baseball tournament that they didn’t seem prepared for The breakfast was actually a nice spread as far as hotel food goes but they could not keep up with the demand ran out of several items They also stopped serving at breakfast at exactly 9 which one a typical day that they weren’t fully booked would have been fine However, with the baseball tournament and lack of food supply there were still many guests waiting in line for food when the staff came around and shut everything down This showed a complete lack of hospitality Lastly the pool towels are very small and some of the most uncomfortable towels I’ve ever used Drying myself with sandpaper may have been betterGood location, but other than that I would not recommend this hotel

Heather Murphy

It’s on the middle of nowhere, not near anything to do! The staff although very nice seemed inadequate to fulfill there duties! We had booked a double with sleeper sofa(all they had left)got up to it & found a king! Not gonna work!! I’m staying with family & needed at least 2 beds and a cot!! Got back downstairs found another guest had a key to a room that was already occupied (what??)The hotel was booked solid(it’s long island on a summer weekend so what else is new)! The next morning before heading out I asked the front desk if housekeeping could change just the double(we were changing guests) he said sure I’ll let them know Got back later to find it hadnt been done(really? This is pathetic)!!!The rates arent cheap either So I will not be staying here ever again!!

Derrick Dubois

I’ve been in the city for the last 15 years for the last 6 years I haven’t seen my grandmother or my mother so seeing them in a Holiday inn that was close to where I’m from in Long Island was nice and their pool wasn’t anything special but it was special to me I also thought it was very considerate that they’re pool was not very deep the lowest level was 3 ft its perfect if you have kids or nieces or nephews In the morning they treat you to a buffet breakfast which if I wasn’t staying in a nursing home I wouldn’t have thought very much of it but after eating hospital food for so long it was like gourmet if you know what I mean

12. Hotel Indigo Long Island – East End, an IHG Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This modern hotel in a low-rise, redbrick building is 2 miles from Splish Splash waterpark and 4 miles from the Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center.Contemporary rooms come with free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, as well as desks, and tea and coffeemaking facilities. Upgraded poolside rooms have patios. Suites are available.Parking is included. There’s a modern bistro and bar with outdoor seating, plus a terrace with an outdoor fireplace. Other amenities include an exercise room, an outdoor pool and a spa. Pets are permitted for a fee.

Things You Need to Know

  • 3 min drive to Splish Splash
  • Guests praised the clean rooms but some complained about the kitchenettes
  • Some guests complained about the bathrooms
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests mentioned “outlet stores” 13 times
  • Guests praised the nightlife
  • Guests liked the outdoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Tommy Shi

Just did five nights and couldn’t have been more pleased with our stay Friendly service, clean, comfortable rooms (esp the beds) and a chill vibe They have pleasant, mellow live music in the evenings (maybe only weekends), a nice pool and a tasty free breakfast

Location is great for exploring the north and south forks of long island Plenty of good restaurants in the immediate area, although the restaurant on site is quite good This is our third stay and we’re already looking forward to coming back next summer

Henry Peterman

Disappointed with my stay IHG listed Hotel Indigo as part of their premier hotel category It’s modern design left much to be desired

Our room was in some disrepair and did not meet the description presented I regularly use Holiday Inn Properties in my travels and found this to be subpar in comparison to their other regular and budget properties I would strong advise those who choose to list this property as a premier property reconsider this classification if other properties under this label are in a similar state The staff was friendly and helpful and was the shining part of my stay It would be hard for me to consider staying at another Indigo property

13. Belvedere Guest House for Men

About this hotel

In a sprawling, Venetian palace-style property overlooking Great South Bay, this adults-only, clothing-optional hotel catering to gay men is 2 minutes’ walk from the beach.With themed decor ranging from baroque to naval, the uniquely styled rooms offer fans, antiques, artwork and shared bathrooms. Upgraded rooms add air-conditioning, TVs, en suite facilities and minifridges. Select rooms have sitting areas, flat-screens, bay views and/or private decks with outdoor showers.Continental breakfast is available. There’s also a deck, a rooftop terrace and an outdoor pool, along with a hot tub, a gym and a chapel. Minimum-stay rules may apply.

Things You Need to Know

  • 3 min drive to Sailors Haven
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Cagedjock

Great place Beautiful setting with lots of great views Amazing sunlight

Cozy rooms It’s like a maze with many little rooms to discover Bathrooms are shared but there are so many bathrooms that we never had any issuesThis place is a true gem

Christopher Kennedy

I haven’t been to the Belvedere in 40 years Not much has changedI had never stayed in the Water Room before, which included a King Size bed, which consisted of 2 twin beds joined together!A hard lump in the middle and one bed higher than the other didn’t leave much room for romance or a good nights sleep for that matter

A chair to sit in would have been a good addition as well We won’t be back

Evan Lacon

The place needs a little attention and a good cleaningThe staff is not very friendlythe young guys have a lot of attitude and the older people that work in the office seemed a bit tired of the whole thingthe pool is much smaller than it looks online and the cushions on the chairs around the pool are so worn out you might as well be laying on the hard chairs themselvesI did like the Shady seating area

14. Hampton Inn Long Island – Brookhaven (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This modern hotel by the Long Island Expressway is 7 miles from fishing and hiking at Southaven County Park, 6 miles from Lake Ronkonkoma and 4 miles from the Suffolk Sports Hall of Fame.Traditional rooms feature free WiFi and flat-screen TVs with HD channels, plus desks and coffeemakers (some add minifridges, microwaves and pull-out sofas). Suites add whirlpool tubs and extra living space.In addition to free parking, hot breakfast (or breakfast bags to go), amenities include an indoor pool, a fitness center and event space.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the rooms, which have refrigerators
  • The rooms have kitchenettes
  • 8 min drive to Holtsville Wildlife & Ecology Center
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the fitness center
  • Guests liked the indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

dd brenne

I am staying 2 nights here I give the hotel workers a 5 hands down The corporation I give a 2

I am writing this review because I can see that the hotel workers are doing a great job, but the corporation leaves them with few resources The hotel workers were excellent, kind and helpful The issue was there was a leak in the ceiling in the breakfast room When we arrived at breakfast I sat in a chair and it was soaking wet I could not see the wet place because it was a fabric color that did not reveal the wet I went and changed and ate breakfast One sweet hustling breakfast attendant was there I did not want to interrupt them, so I moved the chair and got a new one Then I started getting a drip, drop on my head and shoulder I looked up and there was a dripping vent over me I went to the front desk and told the woman there She asked me to see the breakfast attendant I told her the attendant was very busy (she was hustling as the only person working breakfast) and maybe they could get someone else She said yes, again, very apologetic and helpful So we switched tables and ate On the way back up to the room I let the woman at the desk know I had moved the chairs and there was a puddle on the floor I seriously would have mopped it up if I had a mop 🙂 Clearly there is very little staff I know this is happening all over I feel very bad for these workers they need more compensation and respect I thanked the front desk person for doing all they could

JD Roy

This Hampton Inn location is close to a shopping center with several restaurants The rooms are clean and the employees are courteous Overall its a nice place to stay

Two minor things to keep in mind There is a $10 / night parking fee Also, it is right next to a main highway Neither of these things are bad, but something to be aware of when you make your choice of where to stay

15. Danford’s Hotel & Marina (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set on Long Island Sound estuary, this relaxed, harborside hotel is a 2-minute walk from historic Port Jefferson village, known for its shipbuilding, and a 7-minute walk from the Mather House Museum.Cozy, nautical-themed rooms feature Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and iPod docks, plus granite bathrooms with porthole-style mirrors and all-glass showers. Suites add water views, living rooms, fireplaces and/or private balconies. Room service is offered.Amenities include a 24/7 fitness center, an upscale seafood restaurant and marina-front outdoor dining.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests mentioned the rooms are large
  • Walking distance to Long Island Explorium and Harborfront Park
  • Guests mentioned “musical ensembles” 10 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • Guests praised the water views
  • Guests liked the nightlife
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a spa

Feedback From Real Customers

Frank Golio

We just checked in and have always enjoyed our stay here over the years We have come for quick getaways, had parties here with our family and friends and enjoyed the restaurant and club The rooms have always been perfect and the staff wonderful

Until today We booked a specific room because we are traveling with five people 2 beds and a pull out When I arrived I notice one of the papers said $239 but I didn’t think anything of it because I thought to myself the A balance would be taken care of on check out We get to the room and it’s the wrong room Not the room we paid for I go back to the desk and the attendant says “ well yea we ran out of rooms and my manager just left and gave you a discount” no phone call at any point to tell me this as we came from four hours away So I explain this won’t work We need the room we paid for I asked to speak to the manager and she goes in the back and says “ he said he won’t talk to you he is off now, not much more I can do we are sold out, we can make up the sofa” Meanwhile the sofa sleeper was for the two kids so we are still short a bed Terrible customer service and communication! So disappointed

Patricia Bugland

I was at Danford’s for a Sunday Brunch, not a weekend stay The place is so very pretty! Service was great My friends and I were seated at a lovely spot facing the water and enjoyed the fine food in a lovely setting on a gorgeous day

We were all sorry that the pandemic kept us from a return visit for so long, relieved that it survived I hope to be back this summer!

Matthew Repecki

Rooms are in pretty rough shape even after renovation, do not get a street view room if u want to sleep as it is obnoxiously loud Front desk staff is nice but can do little to help other than offer a 20 percent discount Not really worth the price of the rooms at all, is similar to a 2 star hotel

Nice area and views though once you leave the room

16. Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island East End (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

In a commercial area off Interstate 495, this relaxed all-suite hotel is a mile from the Splish Splash Water Park, and 14 miles from a beach on the Atlantic Ocean.Informal studios come with kitchens and living areas, as well as free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs. The 1- and 2-bedroom suites add separate living rooms.Parking and hot breakfast are complimentary. Other amenities include a modern lounge and bar, plus indoor and outdoor pools, a hot tub and a gym. There’s also a convenience store and a coin-operated laundry. Pets are allowed.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms, which have microwaves
  • 3 min drive to Splish Splash
  • Guests liked the service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “outlet stores” 12 times
  • Guests praised the indoor pool and the hot tub
  • Guests liked the modern bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Isabel

Great location! Hotel was clean, the pools were great and I loved the outdoor lounge areas Rooms were clean Used the couch pull out bed and called the front desk for linens

They said that they had to check if they had any linens left for us to use The room description said that linens would be in the closet but they were not there Would’ve been upset if they did not have any linens for us to use but luckily they did Breakfast was good

Robin Lamb

We stayed at the Marriott with our 2 small dogs last night We came to the area to visit our child who is away at college The hotel was perfect! It was very clean

Even though the place was sold out, it didn’t feel crowded or loud We were able to get breakfast without difficulty It was very reasonably priced There are lots of food options nearby The only thing that would make this pet-friendly hotel better would be a gated dog walk area, since the hotel is located on a busy highway Overall, we look forward to staying here again the next time we visit our child

Ricky Long

We enjoyed our stay very much! Staff was courteous, and rooms were clean Abundance of parking The complimentary buffet was top notch

There were to-go boxes ready for guests to eat in their rooms Hot food was individually packaged and constantly topped off by the staff Can’t say enough good things about how clean and well run the breakfast buffet was This Residence Inn is right next to the Tanger Outlet However, in order to get to the outlets, we drove down the road, and then back around We would have walked it, but there’s not direct path across Old Country Road It’s very close to Lavender by the Bay and Windy Acre Farm We definitely would recommend Thank you for making our first overnight stay with our babies as smooth as it could have gone Will be back!

17. The Fox and Owl Inn

  • Address: 1037 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
  • Phone: (631) 509-3669
  • Ratings: 4.7 (70 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : The Fox and Owl Inn
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Warm rooms & suites in a circa-1800s bed-and-breakfast offering BBQ facilities & a porch.

About this hotel

Set In a historic residential area, this charming bed-and-breakfast in a circa-1800s Victorian home is 5 miles from Cedar Beach and a mile from Harborfront Park. Avalon Park And Preserve is 6 miles away.The warm rooms come with antique decor and furnishings, such as chandeliers and clawfoot tubs. They also have free Wi-Fi and private bathrooms. Suites add living areas with sofas.There’s a breakfast buffet, and a living area with sofas. Other amenities include a porch with seating, and bbq facilities.

Things You Need to Know

  • 4 min drive to Harborfront Park
  • 13 min walk to nearest train station
  • Guests praised the service
  • The hotel has a game room
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub

Feedback From Real Customers

Kitty Katara (Andi)

I have never stayed at a B&B before but thought that it would be nice for a vacation to Long Island And dang!!!! I now am going to try and stay here for all my future visits Fox and Owl Inn exceeded any expectations

I stayed with my fiance in the Cove room which was cozy Rebecca and Andrew are so nice, welcoming, and work hard to make everyone’s stay a good one They went out of their way to make sure there was extra food options for me as I am vegan I really enjoyed my stay I definitely can’t speak highly enough about this Inn!!!

Daniel Pena

First time visiting Port Jefferson, came across this gem of a B&B, everything about it is delightful from the accommodations, to the amenities, to the service, to the location Could not have been happier with my stay!! I hope to return soon!! Thank you Rebecca & Andrew My only recommendation is to have the grounds manicured, the lawn is looking a bit unkept

18. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This straightforward hotel is 2.1 miles from Ronkonkoma Beach.Contemporary-styled rooms offer free WiFi, desks, flat-screen TVs, minifridges, microwaves and coffeemakers. Suites add separate living areas and whirlpool tubs.Social spaces include a living room-style lobby and an outdoor courtyard with a fire pit. The American restaurant serves breakfast and dinner as well as all-day drinks, including Starbucks coffee. There’s also a business center with workstations and printers, and 6 meeting rooms. Other amenities include an indoor pool, a whirlpool and an exercise room, as well as a free airport shuttle and on-site parking.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms
  • Some guests disliked the bathrooms
  • 11 min drive to Lakeland County Park
  • 12 min walk to nearest train station
  • Guests liked the friendly service
  • Guests mentioned hot tubs 12 times
  • Guests mentioned fitness centers 10 times

Feedback From Real Customers

Laurie Simmons

Very nice hotel Pool and hot tub indoors, room kept very hot Coin laundry very cheap

Nothing really near hotel except Red Lobster and Smokey Bones No breakfast Large pantry, items expensive Room fridge very tiny so really unable to stock and eat for cheap Stayed on business Not sure I’d pay that price for no breakfast and tiny fridge on a vacation

nasha nicole

The room was very spacious, I took a room with double beds for my kids and myself It was clean, I really love the individually wrapped cups and overall cleanliness even though I take wipes to do a once over as well Tiny fridge but enough room to store leftovers

Quiet and peaceful area It was a really hot day so we used their indoor pool, it was fantastic There is also a hot tub available as well The staff was friendly and my stay was wonderful There are two restaurants in walking distance The Ronkonkoma train station is close by and it’s an easy jump to the LIE On site parking for a fee Small pantry area with plenty of stock

Ruby Bolduc

This place was clean and quiet, the beds were comfortable and the towels were normal size (lol) The rooms were not brand new but the beds were very comfortable and the TV was a 55 in (I have stayed at a few lately with itty bitty TVs and terrible cable service) Everyone who works there that I spoke with was extremely professional and friendly

I would say the only part that was weird was the way they had breakfast for sale items set up in the pantry To that same note, the pantry area was stocked extremely well compared to many other Marriott courtyards that I have stayed at recently I will definitely stay here again

Sharing is caring!