Skip to Content

5 Best 5 star hotels in Waupun, WI (2022)

5 star hotels in Waupun, WI

1. AmericInn by Wyndham, Beaver Dam (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Opposite a shopping mall, this low-key hotel is less than a mile from Highway 151 and 7 miles from the boat rides on Beaver Dam Lake.No-nonsense rooms feature free Wi-Fi and HDTVs. All have minifridges, microwaves and coffeemakers. Suites add furnished balconies and pull-out couches; some have whirlpool tubs. Kids stay at no charge.Car, bus, truck and RV parking is complimentary, as is breakfast served in a relaxed dining room. Other amenities include BBQ grills, a gym and a billiard table, plus a heated indoor pool with a slide.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms, which have kitchenettes
  • Guests praised the bathrooms
  • 6 min drive to Dodge County Historical Society
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a fitness center
  • The fitness center has elliptical machines and treadmills
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub
  • Guests praised the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Thomas Formby

The staff is really helpful and professional The rooms are clean and spacious The amenities really make your stay a value

Being an extended stay client, I appreciate that the staff has been SO helpful and accommodating Makes me feel comfortable, especially being so far away from home I can’t say enough good about the facility and staff!

Angelia Vang

We stayed here for the weekend for a wedding that took place in Columbus, WI Check in was very quick and easy and no check out at front desk needed The overall hotel and room was very clean and well kept

There’s also decent shopping and stores right around the hotel that is very convenient Would definitely stay here again should we be in the area again

Greg Buchwald

The room was comfortable and check-in was easy and fast We stayed 2 nights There was 1 issue: We left by 7AM after our first night and we were gone all day

When we returned at 8PM, our room had not been serviced at all We had wet towels on the floor, etc This is the third Windham property out of 4 in the last couple of months where this has occurred I understand that it is difficult to find people to work right now but rates on rooms are up 50 to 100% in the last 2 years and we should expect at least minimal service such as new towels

2. The Shores of Fox Lake

About this hotel

N10604 Chief Kuno Trail, Fox Lake, WI 53933(920) 928-2576

Things You Need to Know

  • 6 min walk to Fox Lake
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned “Standing rib roast” 13 times
  • Guests liked “fish fry”, mentioned 10 times in reviews
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • Guests praised the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Linda Guenther

My husband and I had Dinner at The Shores last night and I must say “Everything was Phenomenal”! From the Hostess Desk to the Bartenders to the Waitstaff to the Cooks Everyone was VERY professional We had an awesome experience

Kudos to “The Shores”!The food was amazing!! Best steak my husband has ever had! And the Atlantic Salmon was delicious

Jack Coloso

Overall very good experience Called for reservation, let message and received a confirmation call within 30 minutes Was seated about 5 minutes after reservation time

Prime rib was said to be best in area, can’t dispute that, it was delicious 3 different meals ordered and nobody was disappointed Most all staff we encountered were very friendly The only thing from a 5 star would be the French onion soup came out with burnt cheese and they ran out of it very early in the evening Like most other places, they’re short staffed Everyone has was working their tails off

3. Gateway Inn and Suites (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 5 Gateway Dr, Waupun, WI 53963
  • Phone: (920) 324-2500
  • Ratings: 3.4 (103 reviews) Fair
  • Website : Gateway Inn and Suites
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Unassuming rooms & suites in a straightforward pick offering a pool, plus free breakfast & WiFi.

About this hotel

Off Highway 151, this straightforward roadside hotel is less than a mile from downtown Waupun and 2.6 miles from the Marsh Haven Nature Center.Unassuming rooms with traditional decor come with free WiFi, TVs, and tea and coffeemaking equipment. Upgraded rooms and suites offer sofas, separate living areas and/or whirlpool tubs.Complimentary hot breakfast is served in an airy dining room with a fireplace. Additional amenities include an indoor pool, a whirlpool tub and a sauna, as well as meeting space, a 24/7 business center and a cozy lobby with seating.

Things You Need to Know

  • 4 min drive to Marsh Haven Nature Center
  • Guests mentioned beds 11 times
  • Guests mentioned hot tubs 11 times

Feedback From Real Customers

Courtney Wanserski

Horrible!Disgustingly dirty! Didnt have clean bedding to replace the stained ones Only took a photo of the outside while the bed was made, but plenty more nasty gunk (hard and crusty not stained) on the insideThe hot tub in our room wasnt clean, wasnt provided bedding for the pullout

Staff was as helpful as she could be But I will never be returning

Ali

This is apparently the only place that offers public swimming of the indoor pool so we decided to try it out To be honest we were so excited to swim so I didn’t even look the place over well before getting in The first time we went they didn’t have the heat on and the water was quite cold, so we mostly stayed by the hot tub

When I got into the hot tub and sat back to relax, I looked over to my right and seen a USED Band-Aid stuck to the side of the ledge Gross There we’re also little plastic pieces from their old pool tarp floating in the pool I was a little thrown off on how the area looked because the desk lady said the owners had redone the pool area recently But it looked a bit older and unkept When we finished swimming, we grabbed a couple towels and went into the bathroom to get dried off and dressed The bathroom was not very clean and the sink was plugged After I got my little one dried off and dressed, I went to dry myself off more and unfolded a towel that looked to have blood stains all over it I was immediately grossed out When something was mentioned I was rudely snapped back by the owner from my understanding, which in turn stated it was not blood on the towels but rust Whatever was on the towels should not have been put out for people to use Washed or not, Other hotel establishments pull out very stained towels and bedding because it is not appealing and because of certain standards My little one wanted to swim again, so I thought I would give it one more chance even after being talked to so rudely because it was something she wanted to do This time I brought my husband When we came in the desk lady explained a new rule about how public pool people were no longer allowed to use the hotel towels because of a “complaint” and the lady was a little snobby about it which made me uncomfortable and want to leave Since we were already there and had payed, we went swimming Sink wasn’t plugged this time but that Band-Aid was still stuck in the same spot by the hot tub Couple weeks later which made me wonder how often they check or clean the pool area We decided to not come back because of how we were treated and the uncleanliness of the environment I feel the owner or whoever it was could have approached the situation better And after reading some of the other bad reviews, it seems that’s just the way things are We ended up getting invited to a “pool/birthday” party not long ago but it wasn’t any better We were trying to find a table and chairs to set our dry stuff down but most of the sets had yellow puddles on them We didn’t know if it was urine or what but we did notice the moldy water dripping on us from the clearly moldy wood ceiling in the pool room The family who hosted the birthday party was not very happy about the dripping mold either

Sandy Thompson

Very poor service We called the night before to say we would be in late and they still had our room but that’s the only good thing We got there to check in and it appeared we were bothering the person that was working because she had to put down her iPad and get off the couch to check us in

Then we stated we were using a different card to pay for the room then we used for the reservation She said okay but never asked for the card I thought we would finish the payment in the morning since it was midnight Got to our room and the beds were rock hard and the fitted sheets don’t fit so they come off every time you move Go to check out in the morning and we were told they charged the card that the reservation was made with The person working just kept saying sorry but she couldn’t do anything just her manager could She wasn’t willing to contact the manager though to fix the issue I would not recommend them and will not go back! The bathtub didn’t look clean, probably stained, and no plug if anyone needed a bath and we were traveling with a 5 year old so a bath might have had to happen if we were there more than 9 hours

4. AmericInn by Wyndham Waupun (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 204 Shaler Dr, Waupun, WI 53963
  • Phone: (920) 345-1140
  • Ratings: 4.4 (245 reviews) Very good
  • Website : AmericInn by Wyndham Waupun
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Unassuming rooms & suites in a laid-back hotel featuring a bar, plus an indoor pool & a gym.

About this hotel

Off Highway 151, this low-key hotel is 1 mile from the landmark End of the Trail monument and 10 miles from the Horicon National Wildlife Refuge. It’s 20 miles from the Children’s Museum of Fond du Lac.Unfussy rooms with traditional decor provide complimentary Wi-Fi, flat-screens and iPod docks, as well as coffeemakers, minifridges and microwaves. Suites add wet bars, plus sitting areas with pull-out sofas.Free perks include parking and a breakfast buffet. A casual bar serves light fare; there’s also a convenience store, and a patio with BBQ equipment, along with an indoor pool, a hot tub and a gym. Laundry facilities are available.

Things You Need to Know

  • 4 min drive to Marsh Haven Nature Center
  • Guests praised the service
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a restaurant
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a fitness center
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a casino
  • Guests praised the indoor pool
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Alexandria Ingram

We stayed in three different AmericInn hotels during our little vacation this summer This one was definitely not the best First, we booked with this chain because they are pet-friendly

We have one 18 pound pup who is super well-behaved (he’s almost a therapy dog) Someone came up behind us while checking in, so he barked at them because he was startled The woman at the front desk, who was extremely rude the whole time we were here, made a snide comment about how she hoped nobody would complain about our dog You’re a PET-FRIENDLY HOTEL Dogs bark sometimes Babies cry and scream, too, and I hope she wasn’t making similar comments about people’s children Our dog was so good while we were here, and he’s hypoallergenic, so he doesn’t even shed and get hair everywhere We had to pay a pet fee, which is no big deal, but neither of the other two hotels we stayed at made us pay a pet fee The room was nice enough, but it was definitely dirty Not to mention that we specifically requested one king bed and got two instead Not a huge deal, but this place was empty while we were hereThere were actual dirt stains on the shower wall and hair that was definitely not ours There was also pet fur in the carpet (at least I hope it was pet fur) and base boards The towels were in terrible shape (one thread away from giant holes), and it was just an all-around disappointing stay I came in once carrying three bags, my dog’s leash, and some pizza I was greatly struggling but stopped to ask the front desk for some toilet paper, since there was none in our room and the rolls were almost empty I told her our room number (which was the closest one to the desk) and went to our room because I was having a hard time balancing everything and had no more hands She came to give me the toilet paper and snidely stated that she didn’t expect me to “disappear” on her Our room was five feet from the desk All in all, this was disappointing, and it was NOT worth the money I sincerely hope they clean up better next time and get a new desk worker I didn’t even feel comfortable complaining because she was so dismissive and rude!!!! Such a huge bummer, since our stay at the one previously was so wonderful Also, not for nothing, but the wifi and internet was horrible! It barely worked 50% of the time, so don’t plan on working while you’re here Steer clear of this one; there are plenty of others around!

Karla

Stayed there for family wedding yesterday This will be a long post but want to explain the whole situation as well as feedback for those lookingClean hotel, friendly staff, hottub out of service but a nice easy to read sign at front desk with explanation, nice room (we were in a 2 bd queen), and a nice standard breakfast selection (my cousin said the scrambled eggs were some of the best she has ever had at a hotel!)

Not gonna lie, it was stressful for some of the guests ss they were told upon checking in that the hotel was somehow overbooked, they were having issues with their scheduling system, and didnt have any available rooms Alyshia (front desk attendant) and Melanie (Manager that came in on her day off) where doing the best they could to help and eventually got things straightened away I would love to give them both a huge shout out and special thank to Melanie for everything as well as Alyshia for staying calm and cool with the upset guests Thank you!I would stay here again if i ever had to as overall it was a great place and staff

Kellee Stronghold

This was our 6th or 7th time staying there but unfortunately and this visit was a NIGHTMARE! 1STroom was completely full of urine on one of the mattresses had to switch to another room, the 2ND RM the heater and air conditioner unit didn’t work so had to move to a 3rd room! Keys wouldn’t work to get in rooms We are all the way up on the third floor we continually had to go down to the receptionist area they seem to be nice but it was all a facade We missed a dinner, missed a concert that we were supposed to go to

We were supposed to be refunded never got refunded! talked to a manager and two co-workers and have gotten nowhere just keep lying and going in circles

5. The Audubon Hotel and Event Venue (4-star hotel)

About this hotel

Built in 1896, this cozy hotel with a refined, colorful facade is a 4-minute walk from the Mayville Historical Society and 4 miles from Horicon Marsh.The elegant, individually decorated rooms have vintage touches and modern perks including free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, plus whirlpool tubs and writing desks. Suites add sitting areas and armoires; some also come with sitting rooms, bay windows and marble baths.There’s a Creole-inspired restaurant, a spa, and a grand lobby with board games and books.

Things You Need to Know

  • One of the few hotels in the area with air conditioning
  • Walking distance to Mayville Limestone School Museum and Mayville Park Pavilion
  • The hotel has a concierge
  • Guests mentioned beds 15 times
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar
  • The hotel has Wi-Fi

Feedback From Real Customers

Kathy Curtis

We’d made arrangements to check in after hours A person came out from the kitchen and asked if we needed help (We didn’t)

That was the only person we saw There was not even anyone available at checkoutWe three ladies had several issues during our 1-night stayOur room was apparently located above the bar Beginning about 11:00 pm when the 3 of us were just getting to bed , music began blaring & pounding from below, loud enough to vibrate the floor It didn’t let up until nearly 2 amThen unfortunately we were awakened early by the sun There were shades at the windows, but they really needed black out curtainsI was the senior of the group I was not able to get a shower The spa tub was deep & the sides quite high, & there were no grab bars I could not get in itThere was no counter space at all in the bathroom making it difficult to put on makeup or do hairThere was no coffeemaker in the room, but we did find two down by the elevator Though I have a Keurig at home, these were quite different There were no instructions for using themThe facility was clean & the beds were comfortable, but all things considered I would not choose to stay again nor recommend it

Zachary Gappa

Important caution: When they say “our front desk closes at 8pm”, they mean there is no staff on site at all after that time I booked a get-away stay here for my wife She was uncomfortable staying there alone without any staff or security person on site

They lock the front door and that’s about it She spent a couple of hours sitting in the room and then decided she was uncomfortable staying there overnight I expressed this to the hotel and asked for a partial refund since I didn’t feel it was clear on the website that there is no on-site presence at all in the evening – they informed me there would be zero refund as they believed “front desk closes” should be interpreted as zero staffMy wife had some other problems with the hotel room also (small hairs in the bathtub, poor room lighting, etc), but this is my primary caution to other people looking to book this hotel And my only major complaint is the lack of any amount of refund, given that safety concern she had and the fact that she didn’t really use the room They also indicated to her in person that there could be a refund, only to tell me there would be no refund when I sought one afterwards Given how the hotel chose to handle the transaction, we won’t be booking here again

Sharing is caring!